Skip to Main content

  • Scrappy's Italian Deli

Scrappy's Italian Deli

272 Broad Street, Lake Geneva, WI
‌
‌
Scrappy's Food Menu
Grocery / Retail

Featured Items

  • Italian Beef Knockouts

    3 Italian beef eggrolls - Italian Beef, Mozzarella Cheese & Giardiniera
    $9.00

  • The Scrapper

    Turkey, salami, pepperoni, provolone, fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper sauce, red wine vinaigrette, lettuce, red onion, tomatoes, salt pepper, italian oil & seasoning on hoagie roll
    $13.00

  • Tony B Trippin - Grinder

    Italian slaw, Salami, Ham, Pepperoni, capicola, tomato, provolone
    $13.00

Scrappy's Food Menu

Undercut Pies

  • Cheese

    Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $3.00; 12in $10.00; 16in $14.00.
    $3.00+

  • Cheese & Sausage

    Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.00; 12in $12.00; 16in $16.00.
    $4.00+

  • Cheese & Pepperoni

    Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.00; 12in $12.00; 16in $16.00.
    $4.00+

  • Cheese, Sausage & Pepperoni

    Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.50; 12in $14.00; 16in $18.00.
    $4.50+

  • Supreme

    Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.50; 12in $15.00; 16in $20.00.
    $4.50+

  • Italian Beef & Giardenera

    Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.50; 12in $15.00; 16in $20.00.
    $4.50+

  • Chicken alfredo

    Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.50; 12in $15.00; 16in $20.00.
    $4.50+

Sorriso Panino’s

  • Tony B Trippin - Grinder

    Italian slaw, Salami, Ham, Pepperoni, capicola, tomato, provolone
    $13.00

  • Italian Job

    Italian Beef, roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese
    $12.00

Scrappy’s Signature Stacks

  • Bruschetta Boss - Bruschetta Panini Melt

    Bruschetta, Mozzarella Cheese, Balsamic Glaze, Provolone on Panini Bread
    $10.00

  • The Wise Guy - Hot Pastrami on Rye

    Pastrami, Swiss, dill pickle chips, deli mustard on Rye Bread
    $12.00

  • Double Cross - Corned Beef & Pastrami

    Corned Beef, Pastrami, Swiss, red onions, oil and vinegar, deli mustard, lettuce, heirloom tomatoes, on Rye Bread
    $14.00

  • Meatball Mobster

    Chopped Meatballs, Roasted Red Peppers, Grilled Onions, Red Sauce, Mozzarella on Garlic Bread Hoagie
    $14.00

  • Tuscan Kiss - Caprese

    Heirloom Tomatoes, basil, Fresh Mozzarella, prosciutto, balsamic glaze, on Toasted Ciabatta
    $12.00

  • The Scrapper

    Turkey, salami, pepperoni, provolone, fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper sauce, red wine vinaigrette, lettuce, red onion, tomatoes, salt pepper, italian oil & seasoning on hoagie roll
    $13.00

  • Shake Down - Sausage & Pepper Sandwich

    Italian Sausage, Peppers & Onions, Red Sauce, Mozzarella on Garlic Bread Hoagie
    $14.00

  • Chicago Classic - Pepper and Egg sandwich

    Egg, Peppers, Parmesan Cheese, Provolone cheese on Hoagie. Add giardinera (optional).
    $9.00

  • Italian Rooster - Chicken Bruschetta

    Fried chicken, Bruschetta, Mozzarella or Provolone, Pesto, Balsamic Glaze on hoagie
    $12.00

  • Italian Stallion

    Mortadella, Porchetta Cotta, Hot Soppressata, Hot Capicola, Provolone, Lettuce, Red Onions, Tomatoes, Oil and Vinegar, Mayo, on Sesame Italian Roll
    $14.00

  • Underboss - Burrata BLT

    Pesto Mayo, Bacon, Tomatoes, Lettuce, Burrata, Balsamic glaze
    $11.00

  • Tough Guy

    Roast beef, Lettuce, Tomato, Red onions, Mayo, Deli mustard, on a ciabatta roll
    $12.00

  • Kingpin- 3 Cheese portabella panini

    Grilled portabella mushrooms, Fontina cheese, Provolone cheese, Mozzarella cheese, Roasted red peppers, Spinach on italian bread
    $10.00

  • The Snitch

    Thinly sliced Ham, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Italian Dressing on Sesame Italian Roll
    $11.00

  • Beachside Boss

    Ham, Turkey, Cucumber, Provolone cheese, Brown mustard, on rye bread
    $11.00

  • Tommy Gun

    Turkey, Pesto mayo, Provolone cheese, Bacon, spinach, Tomato, on Ciabatta roll
    $13.00

  • Crunchy Guido - 3 Chicken Parm eggrolls w-red sauce

    Fried chicken, Mozzarella cheese, Wonton w-Vodka Sauce, served w-red sauce
    $9.00

  • Italian Beef Knockouts

    3 Italian beef eggrolls - Italian Beef, Mozzarella Cheese & Giardiniera
    $9.00

  • Rocky's Cheesesteak

    $16.00

  • Philly Italiano

    $16.00

Cold Items

  • Tortellini Pasta Salad

    $6.00+

  • Antipasto Pasta Salad

    $6.00+

  • Olive Salad

    $8.00

Deserts

  • Cannoli

    $8.00

Chips

  • Deep River Sea Salt

    $3.00

  • Deep River Salt & Vinegar

    $3.00

  • Deep River Sour Cream & Onion

    $3.00

  • Deep River Zesty Jalapeno

    $3.00

  • Deep River BBQ

    $3.00

  • Deep River Salt & Cracked Pepper

    $3.00

Grocery / Retail

Grocery

  • ALESSI BALSAMIC REDUCTION TRADITIONAL

    ALESSI BALSAMIC REDUCTION TRADITIONAL
    $10.00

  • ALESSI BALSAMIC REDUCTION WHITE

    ALESSI BALSAMIC REDUCTION WHITE
    $10.00

  • ALESSI BREADSTICK GARLIC THIN

    ALESSI BREADSTICK GARLIC THIN
    $5.00

  • ALESSI BREADSTICK ORIGINAL THIN

    ALESSI BREADSTICK ORIGINAL THIN
    $5.00

  • ALESSI PESTO DI LIGURIA

    ALESSI PESTO DI LIGURIA
    $5.00

  • ALESSI SPICE PINE NUTS

    ALESSI SPICE PINE NUTS
    $8.00

  • ALESSI TOMATOES SUN DRIED IN OIL

    ALESSI TOMATOES SUN DRIED IN OIL
    $9.00

  • ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC RASPBERRY

    ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC RASPBERRY
    $8.00

  • ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC RED

    ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC RED
    $8.00

  • ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC WHITE

    ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC WHITE
    $8.00

  • AMBROSI PARMESAN REGGIANO WHITE GOLD GRATED

    AMBROSI PARMESAN REGGIANO WHITE GOLD GRATED
    $9.00

  • AMBROSI PARMESAN REGGIANO WHITE GOLD SHAVED

    AMBROSI PARMESAN REGGIANO WHITE GOLD SHAVED
    $9.00

  • ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI W/ GARLIC & PARSLEY

    ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI W/ GARLIC & PARSLEY
    $5.00

  • ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI WITH ROSEMARY

    ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI WITH ROSEMARY
    $5.00

  • ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI CLASSICO

    ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI WITH SEA SALT
    $5.00

  • BELLADORO COOKIE SHORT BREAD CHERRY JAM

    BELLADORO COOKIE SHORT BREAD CHERRY JAM
    $6.00

  • BORRELLI BISCOTTI ALMOND

    BORRELLI BISCOTTI ALMOND
    $6.00

  • BORRELLI BISCOTTI CHOCOLATE CHIP

    BORRELLI BISCOTTI CHOCOLATE CHIP
    $6.00

  • BORRELLI BISCOTTI PISTACHIO

    BORRELLI BISCOTTI PISTACHIO
    $6.00

  • BORRELLI TOMATO DICED

    BORRELLI TOMATO DICED
    $3.50

  • CARFAGNAS ORIGINAL PASTA SAUCE

    CARFAGNAS ORIGINAL PASTA SAUCE
    $10.00

  • CARFAGNAS POMODORO PASTA SAUCE

    CARFAGNAS POMODORO PASTA SAUCE
    $10.00

  • CARFAGNAS SICILLIANO PASTA SAUCE

    CARFAGNAS SICILLIANO PASTA SAUCE
    $10.00

  • CARFAGNAS VODKA PASTA SAUCE

    CARFAGNAS VODKA PASTA SAUCE
    $10.00

  • COLAVITA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN

    COLAVITA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN
    $11.00

  • DECECCO PASTA BUCATINI #15

    DECECCO PASTA BUCATINI #15
    $4.00

  • DECECCO PASTA CAVATAPPI

    DECECCO PASTA CAVATAPPI
    $4.00

  • DECECCO PASTA FETTUCCINE

    DECECCO PASTA FETTUCCINE
    $4.00

  • DECECCO PASTA FUSILLI SPINACH

    DECECCO PASTA FUSILLI SPINACH
    $4.00

  • DECECCO PASTA LINGUINE

    DECECCO PASTA LINGUINE
    $4.00

  • DECECCO PASTA PENNE RIGATE

    DECECCO PASTA PENNE RIGATE
    $4.00

  • DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI

    DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI
    $4.00

  • DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI SPINACH

    DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI SPINACH
    $4.00

  • DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI WHOLE WHEAT

    DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI WHOLE WHEAT
    $4.00

  • GRAND AROMA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN GARLIC

    GRAND AROMA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN GARLIC
    $12.00

  • GRAND AROMA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN TUSCAN HERB

    GRAND AROMA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN TUSCAN HERB
    $12.00

  • KRINOS ANTIPASTI LEMON FETA

    KRINOS ANTIPASTI LEMON FETA
    $7.00

  • KRINOS ANTIPASTI SALAD

    KRINOS ANTIPASTI SALAD
    $7.00

  • KRINOS OLIVES JUBILEE ASSORTMENT

    KRINOS OLIVES JUBILEE ASSORTMENT
    $7.00

  • KRINOS OLIVES KALAMATA PITTED

    KRINOS OLIVES KALAMATA PITTED
    $7.00

  • KRINOS OLIVES SALAD GREEK FETA

    KRINOS OLIVES SALAD GREEK FETA
    $7.00

  • MARCONI GIARDINIERA HOT

    MARCONI GIARDINIERA HOT
    $7.00

  • MARCONI GIARDINIERA MILD

    MARCONI GIARDINIERA MILD
    $7.00

  • MARCONI OLIVES MUFFALETTA

    MARCONI OLIVES MUFFALETTA
    $9.00

  • MUTTI TOMATO PUREE

    MUTTI TOMATO PUREE
    $5.50

  • MUTTI TOMATOES CRUSHED

    MUTTI TOMATOES CRUSHED
    $4.00

  • MUTTI TOMATOES WHOLE PEELED

    MUTTI TOMATOES WHOLE PEELED
    $5.50

  • NEGRONI ANTIPASTO CLASSICO SLICED

    NEGRONI ANTIPASTO CLASSICO SLICED
    $10.50

  • NEGRONI GENOA/ASIAGO/TARALLI

    NEGRONI GENOA/ASIAGO/TARALLI
    $6.00

  • NEGRONI MORTADELLA PISTACHIOS SLICED

    NEGRONI MORTADELLA PISTACHIOS SLICED
    $8.00

  • NEGRONI PROSCIUTTO SLICED

    NEGRONI PROSCIUTTO SLICED
    $9.00

  • NEGRONI SALAMI TRIO SLICED

    NEGRONI SALAMI TRIO SLICED
    $10.50

  • NEGRONI SOPRESSATA SALAMI SLICED

    NEGRONI SOPRESSATA SALAMI SLICED
    $9.00

  • SARTORI ASIAGO ROSEMARY CHEESE WEDGE

    SARTORI ASIAGO ROSEMARY CHEESE WEDGE
    $8.00

  • SARTORI BALSAMIC BELLAVITANO CHEESE

    SARTORI BALSAMIC BELLAVITANO CHEESE
    $8.00

  • SARTORI BELLAVITANO TOMATO BASIL CHEESE

    SARTORI BELLAVITANO TOMATO BASIL CHEESE
    $8.00

  • SARTORI CHEDDAR FARMHOUSE CHEESE

    SARTORI CHEDDAR FARMHOUSE CHEESE
    OUT OF STOCK
    $7.00

  • SARTORI CHEDDAR ITALIAN HERB CHEESE BITES

    SARTORI CHEDDAR ITALIAN HERB CHEESE BITES
    $7.00

  • SARTORI CHEDDAR MONTAMORE CHEESE BITES

    SARTORI CHEDDAR MONTAMORE CHEESE BITES
    OUT OF STOCK
    $7.00

  • SARTORI MERLOT BELLAVITANO CHEESE

    SARTORI MERLOT BELLAVITANO CHEESE
    $8.00

  • SARTORI MERLOT CHEESE SPREAD

    SARTORI MERLOT CHEESE SPREAD
    $8.50

  • SARTORI GARLIC & HERB CHEESE SPREAD

    SARTORI GARLIC & HERB CHEESE SPREAD
    $8.50

  • BARILLA ORECCHIETTE PASTA

    BARILLA ORECCHIETTE PASTA
    $6.00

  • PIANCONE CACCAVELLE PASTA

    PIANCONE CACCAVELLE PASTA
    $12.00

  • PIANCONE GNOCCHI

    PIANCONE GNOCCHI
    $6.00

  • PIANCONE TAGLIATELLE PASTA

    PIANCONE TAGLIATELLE PASTA
    $9.00

  • PIANCONE FUSILLI PASTA

    PIANCONE FUSILLI PASTA
    $9.00

  • COFFEE BEANS DECAF

    DECAF BEANS by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
    $14.00

  • COFFEE GROUND DECAF

    DECAF GROUND by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
    $14.00

  • COFFEE BEANS ARTISAN

    ARTISAN ROAST BEANS (Medium Roast) by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
    $14.00

  • COFFEE GROUND ARTISAN

    ARTISAN GROUND COFFEE (Medium Roast) by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
    $14.00

  • COFFEE BEANS WAKE THE LAKE

    WAKE THE LAKE BEANS (Dark Roast) by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
    $14.00

  • COFFEE GROUND WAKE THE LAKE

    WAKE THE LAKE GROUND (Dark Roast) by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
    $14.00

  • MIKES NUTS ORIGINAL

    $6.00

  • MIKES NUTS HABENRO

    $6.00

  • MIKES NUTS GHOST PEPPER

    $6.00

  • BARILLA PASTINA STARS

    BARILLA PASTINA STARS
    $4.00

  • PRIMAL PEPPERONI BEEF STICK

    $6.00

  • PRIMAL ORIGINAL BEEF STICK

    $6.00

  • PRIMAL JALAPENO BEEF STICK

    $6.00

The Wise Guy - Hot Pastrami on Rye

$12.00

Pastrami, Swiss, dill pickle chips, deli mustard on Rye Bread

Customize your item

Wise Guy Modifiers

Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Scrappy's Italian Deli Location and Hours

(262) 233-9490
272 Broad Street, Lake Geneva, WI 53147
Open now • Closes at 3:59AM
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement